First Submission Cycle Retrospective
This week, we completed reviewing manuscripts and have now contacted all of the submitting authors (we hope — if we somehow missed one, please let us know). This first time around, we're doing everything manually so that we're certain we understand exactly what's happening. Since we didn't have a workflow, we've had a few false starts and miscommunications along the way, but it's all worked surprisingly well.
We considered signing up for Moksha (or a similar system) to manage submissions, but the pricing seemed a bit forbidding. We're working on another post in the coming weeks where we plan to lay out and discuss the financials for Elegant Lich and our plans going forward. But suffice it to say that we'd much rather spend our money paying authors (and, someday, artists) than for a submission system. Note: we do know how much work it goes into building systems like Moksha — we are both former software professionals that have authored systems like that.
We were a bit surprised by the number of manuscripts we received. We were hoping to receive enough manuscripts for one issue. Instead, we got more than enough for several issues. It was very hard to reject so many good stories.
We were initially cautious of over-prescribing what we hoped to receive. We really didn't want people to self censor. And, quite honestly, we didn't really even know what we were looking for and so we left it intentionally broad. But we think we came away from the first reading period with much clearer ideas of the kinds of things that resonate with us.
We like complete stories. We like stories where there is a problem that is satisfyingly resolved by the end. One antipattern we saw a number of times were manuscripts where, instead of a complete story, it's more like the first chapter of a novel. This is familiar to us since it's what one of us frequently did as a novice writer.
Part of what makes a story ending satisfying is not leaving unnecessary ambiguity. Famously, people have joked that the New Yorker takes manuscripts and tears off the last two pages before publishing. We hate that.
We also generally prefer endings that are pleasing. Some people like tragic endings: we prefer more light-hearted endings. We're in camp "happily ever after" or "happily for now" as opposed to ones where the protagonist kills themself. Or is immolated in dragon fire.
We each like stories that resonate with our personal topics of interest. Phil is a big finance nerd, so stories that had some kind of economic hook were a draw with him. Steve is a biologist, so stories that had an ecological, botanical, or zoological angle were more likely to catch his eye. We're both language nerds, so stories with a linguistic theme work for both of us.
A lot of editors say they're looking for something new. "Surprise me!" they say. This is perhaps less true of us: we actually can very much enjoy a story that feels well-worn and comfortable. Not that surprises can't also be delightful.
We did not collect detailed demographic data, so we have no insight into the racial make-up of the submitting authors. We do appear to have a pretty good balance among genders. And good queer representation among the stories.
One potential blind spot for us may be poetry. We received a good number of poetry submissions, but none appealed to us enough to displace the really excellent submissions we simply had to select.
We were pleased to receive stories from all over the world. Since we were not being intentional about selections, we were not sure, initially, if we actually had selected any international stories. But, after going back and checking, we can see that accepted several. This was reassuring.
We've seen people say that it's not good enough to just read manuscripts and pick the best ones. Because of systemic issues, that very easily leads to a bunch of stories by white men. But our experience is that, this time at least, just picking the best stories brought us a nicely diverse set of authors.
At this point, we haven't made any firm decisions about going forward. We might want to switch away from having open periods and, instead, simply accept stories for future issues on a rolling basis. We were generally pleased that we got a good balance without creating intentional carve-outs for particular kinds of stories, but we might consider it for poetry. Or new authors. We might also look for additional editors to offer their expertise.
In any event, it's been a fascinating experience and we're looking forward to getting the first issue out. We know folks are going to love these stories because they are really amazing. We hope you will have as much fun reading our first issue and we're having while producing it!

Comments